You are currently viewing How to Choose a Roofer in 7 Steps

How to Choose a Roofer in 7 Steps

Your roof is a critical part of your home that protects you and yours from the elements, contributes to energy efficiency, and impacts the appearance and also value of your property. Choosing a roofing company is an important decision, so you should feel informed and confident in choosing a company that will complete your project with efficiency, quality, and care.

Find the right roofing company isn’t just about finding a service provider; it’s about partnering with a company that understands your specific requirements, respects your budget, and ensures a hassle-free, high-quality roofing experience.

A quality roofing company brings more than just skill and materials to your project.

They bring reliability, expertise, and peace of mind. The right company will ensure that your roofing project is completed on time, within your budget, and to the highest standards of quality.

They will use durable materials, employ skilled workers, and provide a warranty that guarantees their workmanship. A reputable roofing company will be licensed, insured, and compliant with all local building codes, which protects you as a homeowner from any legal or financial liabilities.

Here are the 7 steps you can take to find the right roofer for your home:

  1. Initial Considerations: Understand your roofing needs and set a realistic budget.
  2. Researching Roofing Companies: How to compile a list of potential companies and check their credentials and certifications.
  3. Evaluating Roofing Companies: How to assess past work, reputation, insurance, and warranty offerings.
  4. Getting and Comparing Quotes: How to request detailed estimates and effectively compare them.
  5. Making the Final Decision: What to consider before making the final decision, including consultations, contract evaluations, and negotiations.
  6. Preparing for the Roofing Project: Understand the logistics, from planning to the installation process.
  7. Post-Installation Considerations: How to conduct a final inspection and maintain your new roof.

By the end of this guide, you’ll be equipped with all the necessary knowledge to confidently choose the best roofing company that meets your specific needs and ensures a durable, high-quality roof over your head.

Finished roof replacement job on a residential home

Initial Considerations For Your Roofing Project

Before starting the search for a roofing company, first you need a clear understanding of your roofing needs and budget. This initial groundwork not only guides your decision-making process, but also ensures clear communication with potential contractors, leading to more accurate quotes and better project outcomes.

Types of Roofing Projects

  • New Roof Installation: If you’re working on a new construction project, you’ll have the freedom to choose from a wide range of materials and styles. In this instance you’ll be looking for a roofing contractor who can coordinate well with the other builders.
  • Repair: Roof repairs are often urgent and can range from minor leak fixes to replacing damaged shingles. Understanding the extent of damage and the urgency of repair will help find a company that is available in a reasonable time frame.
  • Replacement: A roof replacement is necessary when repairs are no longer sufficient. This is often a significant investment and requires careful consideration of materials and quality of workmanship, because you want this to last a long time.

When it comes to materials for your roofing project, you have a variety of options such as asphalt shingles, metal, tile, and slate, each offering unique advantages and drawbacks in terms of durability, cost, appearance, and maintenance requirements. The style of your roof is another crucial aspect to consider, as it should harmonize with the overall aesthetics of your building. Elements like color, texture, and architectural design are significant in this regard, influencing the final appearance of your roof.

Additionally, it’s important to think about incorporating features like skylights, gutter systems, and proper ventilation. These components are not just functional enhancements; they can significantly impact the overall cost of your roofing project while improving its efficiency and value.

Factors Influencing Costs of Roofing Projects

When budgeting for your roofing project, it’s wise to plan for unexpected expenses that may arise. A key strategy is to allocate an additional 10-20% of your estimated budget as a contingency fund. This extra amount can cover unforeseen issues such as necessary structural repairs or delays caused by unpredictable weather conditions. Beyond immediate concerns, consider the long-term financial implications of your choices. Investing in higher quality materials or opting for additional features, like improved insulation, can yield significant savings in the long run. These choices, while potentially increasing initial costs, can lead to lower energy bills and reduced maintenance costs over time, offering a valuable return on investment. This balanced approach to budgeting ensures not only that you are prepared for unexpected challenges but also that you are making cost-effective decisions for the future health of your property.


When planning a roofing project, the choice of materials is a crucial factor that significantly impacts the overall cost. High-quality materials generally command a higher price tag; however, they offer greater durability and longevity, which can be a wise investment in the long term. These materials are more resistant to wear and tear, and they can better withstand harsh weather conditions, making them a cost-effective choice over time despite the initial expense.


The labor cost is another important consideration in your roofing project. This expense is largely influenced by the complexity of the project and the skill level of the roofing team. More intricate roofing jobs that require a higher level of craftsmanship or specialized skills will naturally incur higher labor costs. Additionally, the duration of the project and the number of workers needed also play a role in determining the overall labor expense.

Size & Shape of Roof

The size and complexity of your roof are directly proportional to the cost of the project. Larger roofs require more materials and more man-hours to complete, which increases the overall cost. Additionally, if your roof has a complex design, such as multiple slopes, angles, or unique architectural features, this complexity necessitates more specialized labor and materials, further elevating the cost. These factors must be carefully evaluated when planning your budget for a roofing project.


Lastly, the geographic location of your property can significantly influence the cost of your roofing project. Material costs and availability can vary greatly depending on where you live. Certain materials may be more expensive or less readily available in your region, affecting the overall material cost. Similarly, labor rates can differ based on the local economy and the standard pricing in your area. This geographic variation is an essential factor to consider when setting your budget and expectations for the roofing project.

By thoroughly assessing your roofing needs and carefully planning your budget, you lay a solid foundation for your roofing project. This preparation not only streamlines the process of choosing the right roofing company but also ensures that the final outcome aligned with your expectations and requirements.

The Reliable Roofing & Restoration Trailer parked in front of a home where a team of roofers are working.

Researching Potential Roofing Companies

When beginning your search for a roofing company, it’s important to consider both local and national firms. Local companies often provide a more personalized service and have a better understanding of regional roofing needs and local building codes. On the other hand, national companies might offer more standardized services and potentially have access to a broader range of materials and resources. Both have their merits, and the choice depends on your specific project requirements and preferences.

Referrals and recommendations are invaluable in this process. Speak to friends, family, or neighbors who have had recent roofing work done. Their experiences can provide insights into the reliability and quality of work of various companies. Also, consider consulting online reviews and ratings, but be mindful of the credibility of these sources.

Check Credentials and Certifications

Verifying the credentials and certifications of a roofing company is crucial to protect your investment. Start by ensuring they meet all licensing requirements. In Texas, for example, you can use the Roofing Contractors Association of Texas license lookup tool to verify if a company is properly licensed. This step is vital for ensuring that the company adheres to state regulations and industry standards.

Additionally, look for industry certifications and memberships, as these often indicate a higher standard of professionalism and expertise. Certifications from bodies like the National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA) or local roofing contractor associations add a layer of trust and assurance about the company’s capability and commitment to quality.

Evaluating Roofing Companies

The process of obtaining and evaluating roofing quotes is a critical step in your roofing project. It involves not only gathering detailed estimates from various roofing companies but also understanding and comparing these estimates to make an informed choice. This stage requires careful attention to detail to ensure that you are making comparisons based on equivalent offerings and true value, not just the initial price. The following sections will guide you through how to request these detailed estimates and compare them in a way that aligns with your project’s needs and budget.

Reviewing Past Work and Portfolio

A critical step in evaluating roofing companies is reviewing their past work and portfolio. This gives you a sense of the quality of their workmanship. Look for before and after photos and testimonials from previous clients, which can provide insights into their experience with the company. A portfolio of completed projects can demonstrate the company’s capability in handling projects similar to yours, their attention to detail, and their ability to deliver aesthetically pleasing results.

Assessing Reputation and Reliability

The reputation and reliability of a roofing company are vital. Online reviews and ratings can be a helpful resource in gauging previous customers’ satisfaction. Websites like Yelp, Google Reviews, and HomeAdvisor offer a platform for customers to share their experiences.

Verifying Insurance and Warranty Offers

Ensuring that the roofing company has adequate insurance coverage, including liability and workers’ compensation insurance, is crucial. This protects you from any liabilities in case of accidents or injuries on your property during the project. Furthermore, inquire about the warranty terms the company offers for both materials and labor. A reputable roofing company will provide warranties that guarantee the quality of their work and the materials used, offering you peace of mind and protection for your investment.

Roofing contractor keeping a residential roof in good condition with proper maintenance

Getting and Comparing Roofing Quotes

Before diving into the specifics of requesting detailed estimates, it’s essential to understand the broader context of getting and comparing roofing quotes. This phase is more than just collecting numbers; it’s about preparing to assess the value and comprehensiveness of the quotes you will receive. It sets the stage for a detailed analysis of what each roofing company offers, ensuring you can make comparisons on a level playing field.

Requesting Detailed Estimates

When seeking quotes from roofing companies, it’s essential to request detailed estimates. A comprehensive quote should include a breakdown of all costs, including materials, labor, and any additional expenses. Understanding these cost breakdowns is crucial for comparing different quotes effectively. It ensures that you are comparing like for like and that there are no hidden costs.

Comparing Quotes Fairly

In comparing quotes, it’s important to perform a price versus value analysis. Don’t just focus on the bottom line; consider the quality of materials, the reputation of the company, and the scope of services included. Be wary of any quotes that are significantly lower than others, as this could indicate a compromise in quality or hidden costs.

Making the Final Decision

Moving from the decision-making process to actual meetings with roofing contractors marks a significant step in your roofing project. This is where your preliminary selections are tested against real-world interactions. Meeting with contractors provides a tangible sense of the company’s approach to your project, allowing you to ask critical questions and gauge their expertise and customer service firsthand.

Meeting with the Roofing Contractors

Before making your final decision, meet with the roofing contractors. Use this opportunity to ask specific questions about the project, timeline, and their approach. Gauge their communication and customer service skills, as these are important indicators of their professionalism and how they will handle your project.

Evaluating the Contract and Final Agreement

Review the contract carefully. It should clearly outline the scope of work, materials to be used, timeline, cost, warranty information, and payment terms. Don’t hesitate to negotiate terms if necessary, and ensure all your concerns are addressed before finalizing the agreement.

"Secure Your Home with Reliable Roofing Restoration and a Clean Deck Installation"

Preparing for the Roofing Project

The transition from the broader preparation for the roofing project to focusing on planning and logistics signifies a shift from conceptual to practical aspects. This phase is where you’ll start to map out the specifics of how the roofing project will unfold, from timelines to the necessary preparations at your property, ensuring everything is set for a smooth execution.

Planning and Logistics

Coordinate with the roofing company to understand the project timeline and scheduling. Make necessary preparations for your home and property to accommodate the roofing work, considering aspects like access to the site, protection of your property, and noise management.

Understanding the Installation Process

Familiarize yourself with the steps involved in the roofing process. Clear communication with the roofing company throughout the project is vital to ensure that everything is proceeding according to plan and to address any issues promptly.

Post-Installation Considerations

After the installation of your new roof, the focus shifts to post-installation considerations, starting with a detailed final inspection. This stage is critical in ensuring that the work meets your standards and expectations. Conducting a thorough inspection allows you to address any concerns immediately, securing the investment you’ve made in your property’s roofing.

Conducting a Final Inspection of Your Roof

After the installation, conduct a thorough inspection of the work. Use a checklist to ensure all aspects of the project meet the agreed standards. If there are any issues, address them with the roofing company immediately.

Maintaining Your New Roof

Regular maintenance is key to prolonging the life of your roof. Follow maintenance tips provided by the roofing company and schedule professional inspections periodically to identify and address any potential issues early.

Reliable Roofing & Restoration truck at a home performing inspections on the residential home roof

Get a quote from Reliable Roofing & Restoration

Ready to ensure your roof is in top condition? Contact Reliable Roofing & Restoration today for a professional and detailed quote. Our experienced team is committed to providing quality roofing solutions tailored to your needs. Don’t wait to secure the best care for your roof. Get in touch now and take the first step towards a durable, beautiful, and reliable roof.

Choose your city below to request your quote from Reliable Roofing & Restoration and experience top-notch service and expertise!